Monday, 6 July 2026 · Independent · Unbought
Latest
Britain funds the wind farms. SSE and Equinor bank the profits.■Trump’s $1.4bn crypto haul built on supporters’ $3.8bn losses■Israeli strike kills mother, baby in Gaza’s ‘safe zone’■Seven PMs, no votes: Burnham gets Number 10■Congress unmasks whistleblowers under child-safety rules■Netanyahu’s own spies reject destruction claim■Britain funds the wind farms. SSE and Equinor bank the profits.■Trump’s $1.4bn crypto haul built on supporters’ $3.8bn losses■Israeli strike kills mother, baby in Gaza’s ‘safe zone’■Seven PMs, no votes: Burnham gets Number 10■Congress unmasks whistleblowers under child-safety rules■Netanyahu’s own spies reject destruction claim■
News

Westminster tells Scotland’s parliament its vote does not count

Scotland's parliament voted to demand independence referendum powers. Westminster refused. The SNP's push for a second Scottish independence vote faces legal and political barriers as the constitutional standoff intensifies.

People's Britain
Westminster tells Scotland's parliament its vote does not count
Image: Mogens Engelund / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

The Scottish Parliament has voted to demand the powers to hold a second independence referendum; the Starmer government has refused. The constitutional standoff the SNP has been building toward since 2014 is now openly live.

Holyrood votes; London says no

The vote was the first item of business in the newly-constituted parliament that sat after the 7 May 2026 Holyrood elections. First Minister John Swinney tabled the demand as a deliberate opening signal: this parliament considers independence its primary business.

Westminster’s response came within days. Under the Scotland Act 1998, the constitution is a reserved matter. Any referendum requires a Section 30 order, a formal transfer of powers that only Westminster can grant. The Starmer government has inherited and confirmed the previous government’s position: no Section 30.

That position is legally sustainable. The Supreme Court ruled in November 2022 that Holyrood cannot legislate for a referendum unilaterally, without Westminster’s consent. The devolution settlement Scotland voted for in 1997 built in this constraint. Pro-union voices will note the route is clear: secure a UK-wide mandate, or persuade Westminster to agree. The SNP has done neither to London’s satisfaction.

The mandate question

The SNP’s difficulty is that the week of the referendum vote is also the week Peter Murrell, former SNP chief executive and husband of Nicola Sturgeon, admitted in court to embezzling more than £400,000 from the party. Opposition MSPs have called for a Holyrood inquiry. Swinney is facing questions about what he knew and when. A party leading a demand for democratic self-determination while managing a major internal corruption case carries a weight its opponents will not let it put down.

Whether a majority of Scots currently support independence is a question the latest polling needs to answer. What the Holyrood vote does settle is that the elected parliament has put the question formally to Westminster, and Westminster has formally declined to answer it.

That is a constitutional position the Starmer government chose. The people of Scotland will be asked to weigh it.

devolutionholyroodindependencejohn-swinneykeir-starmerscotlandsection-30snp